Purchases made through my links help support this website, at no additional cost to you. Details.
Every year, new art galleries and crafts shops open. Often, they’re launched on a shoestring.
They need consigned items to sell.
Every year, new artists and crafters decide that this is the year they’re going to launch their careers.
They need places to show their artwork.
It could be a perfect partnership for your artwork or crafts.
But… is it?
Is Consignment Right for Your Art and Craft Items?
First, can you afford to consign your work? If you need income this week, you’ll do better if you can find a shop to buy your work, outright.
On the other hand, it can be brilliant business strategy to consign your art in a shop that becomes a local (or tourist) favorite.
Consignment works like this: You provide artwork for the gallery or shop. When it sells, you get part of the selling price, and the shop gets the rest. It’s not unusual to see a 30-70 split (the shop keeps 30%) or a 70-30 split (the shop keeps 70%).
The latter should probably be avoided.
In a perfect world, the split is about 50/50. After all, you’ve put time, materials, skill, and originality into your work. The shop is showcasing your work, providing valuable wall, floor or counter space for it.
Consignment can be great, ho-hum, or a nightmare. There are many factors.
Do Your Art and the Shop’s Style Actually Match?
Does the shop or gallery have a style, and – if so – is it a match for your work?
Just as important: Are the shop’s standards high enough?
Your art can shine in a setting with a good mix. However, if visitors take one look at most of the art and say, “Ick,” they may never even see your work.
Or, if the shop can’t find enough good artists and it’s obviously half-empty, that can disappoint visitors. They won’t stay, browse, and buy.
However, if the shop owner does business with a collection of great artists, you can be in fabulous company.
That can help you build your reputation while you increase your income.
Visit your markets regularly and be sure that your work is shown in the best possible light.
Consigning Your Art: Prices and Paydays
How soon will you be paid? If you aren’t paid within 30 days after the work sells, you may want to look for better opportunities.
Who is setting the prices, and are they in the correct range? If you’re new and the shop owner is as well, consider getting a second opinion about the prices. Items won’t sell if they’re priced too high or too low. (From my experience, items are generally underpriced. If your art isn’t selling, try a higher price for two weeks and see if that helps.)
Supply and Demand Can Vary Widely
In the past, I’ve worked with multiple consignment shops and galleries each summer. Some of them will succeed and some will fail. However, a few will sell my work so rapidly, I may have to phase out the less successful shops, just to meet demand.
Even though I’ve supplied galleries and shops for many years, I still can’t predict which items and which shops will be successful.
It’s important to be on good terms with the shops you deal with. Open communications — and flexibility — are vital.
Ask about Insurance
Discuss risks with the shop owner.
If there’s a fire, or the sprinkler system dumps water on everything in the shop, or if your work is stolen, what happens? Either you or the shop owner (or both) should have insurance, or be willing to cover the risks.
The shop owner may want you to carry insurance, as well. For example, if you’re making children’s toys, be sure you have liability coverage. It could be a shock — and a huge expense — if you have to recall 200 wibbly-wobbly toys because the manufacturer recalled the plastic eyes that you used.
(That said, those kinds of disasters are rare. Insurance can turn disasters into speed bumps instead of career stoppers.)
Consigning: Flexibility is a BIG Plus
Although I wholesale some of my crafts to shops, I like to work with at least 50% consignment galleries each summer. (That’s my favorite tourist season in New England.)
The reason is simple: I love the flexibility of working on consignment.
If I get tired of making a particular item, I can simply discuss alternative products with the shop owner.
If a line of products doesn’t sell, I can take it back and place it in another market where it will sell. And, I can put different items in the shop where they collected dust. Everyone wins!
If I’ve committed to a shop and delivering the art is more trouble (or expense) than I expected, I can renegotiate terms.
Mix It Up!
Generally, I wholesale (to shops that buy from me, outright) enough crafts to cover my basic expenses.
After that, I focus on consignment shops and galleries.
I negotiate good commissions, I work closely with new shop owners, and we all have fun.
I work primarily with seasonal shops and galleries… stores that open in June and close when the tourists go home.
I work all winter, building my inventory, and then I can take most of the summer off. Most of my ‘work’ in the summer involves visiting my favorite tourist areas, checking on shops, and delivering products.
Then, I go to the beach. Or the mountains.
Contracts Can Be Essential
Consignment shops and galleries can be a great way to launch your arts and crafts career. You can reduce the stress on both sides, by having a clear agreement with each shop owner.
Start with a standard contract, and modify it to suit your needs.
Here are some sample contracts, online:
Sample Artist-Gallery Consignment Agreement, from Michael Dunn
Sample Consignment Agreement for Artists, from Mark Henson
Consignment Agreement Contract – free sample
Some “worst case” advice, from attorney Richard Stim: Consigning Your Arts and Crafts
Learn More at Your Public Library
It’s smart to consult books about consignment art sales and artist-gallery consignment contracts. Here are a couple worth asking for at your public library.
Business and Legal Forms for Crafts
3 thoughts on “Art Consignment for Beginners”
Hello. Thank you for the well written article. I am on the other end whereby I am contemplating opening up a retail arts store and would like some advice on how to prepare a business plan. The main challenge is that
(1) I do not yet know what works of art I will sell given that I plan to showcase local artists works
(2) not sure what I will yet price them it
Given this uncertainty, it is hard for me to arrive at volume , sales and pricing projections.
Any thoughts would be very much so appreciated.
I’m not red-hot at formal business plans, and usually get a book from the library to follow step-by-step.
That said, I’d approach local business owners, particularly gift shops. Ask them how well local art — and art in general — sell for them. The enthusiasm of their responses will give you an idea of how conservative to be in your projections.
For selling prices, check eBay for comparable works, preferably in your area. That’ll give you a general idea.
Go to a few local meetings of artists’ clubs and organizations. Talk with them about prices, volume, and so on. That’s probably your best resource, not only for your business plan but also for prospective consigners… and customers. (Artists tend to buy art, as well as create it.)
You do an amazing job, writing and narrating, I am glad I found you. Everything I have read has given me so much insight.